Skip to main content
Book Review
Reviewed: 19 November 2025

Murder in York

by: J.R. Ellis

Yorkshire Murder Mysteries, Book 12

  • Rating: full starfull starfull starfull starstar outline (4.0/5)

Go on a ghost tour and end up investigating a murder 

While at a less-than-inspiring training course, DCI Oldroyd takes a break for a ghost tour. Thinking the tour will give him a bit of history about the area, DCI Oldroyd instead finds a dead body. The victim, a largely disliked property owner. There are plenty of suspects, and things worsen when a second body is found. Oldroyd skips the rest of the training course and, with Andy, his trusty left hand, investigates. His trusty right hand, Steph, is on another assignment. Given the closeness to the intended release date, I could not help but draw similarities between the first victim to Scrooge. There were so many possible suspects it almost seemed as though the cause might not get resolved. 

Is Oldroyd looking to return? What would he do with his days? While I know that eventually this will occur, it is not a day that I am looking forward to. There is also some future planning for Andy and Steph.

As with all the books in this series so far, the pace has been great, the story captivating, and the narration on point. I enjoyed on things evolved with this series and the characters. 

I also like how this book can be read standalone without feeling like missing something. It also works great when it has been a while since reading the previous book.

Thank you, #Netgalley and #ThomasMercer, for the early read and the opportunity to share my thoughts.

Happy reading!

Release Date: 18-November-2025

Plot Summary

In the ancient city of York, winter brings Christmas markets, cold weather…and murder.

Snow dusts the cobbled streets of York as tourists flock to its famous Christmas markets. But for DCI Oldroyd, what starts as a peaceful evening on a ghost tour quickly turns deadly.

The tour guide’s grim discovery is no theatrical performance—he finds the body of Henry Marlow, a notorious local landlord, in the doorway of a derelict building. Oldroyd soon has no shortage of a resentful ex-wife, angry tenants, and even the guide who knows every secret passage of the old city.

As festive lights sparkle above the narrow passageways of York, darkness gathers below when a second body is found in the shadow of the ancient cathedral. Can Oldroyd untangle the web of secrets and lies before anyone else dies? As the holiday season approaches, it seems the killer is planning on making this a Christmas to remember—for all the wrong reasons…